Serving Northern St. Louis County, Minnesota

Bay View threatens suit against Town Board


GREENWOOD TWP- Vermilion Ventures, doing business as BayView Lodge, is threatening litigation against the Greenwood Town Board. The action, called a Notice of Claim, is the first step that is taken when pursuing a legal judgement against a governmental unit over alleged losses or injuries.

The Notice claims that the township’s actions have had a “chilling effect” on the First Amendment rights of the claimant, noting that music is a form of expression entitled to protection. In addition the Notice claims that the township is drafting an “Ex Post Facto” conditional use permit to reflect actions taken in 1999, which is a violation of both Minnesota and township statutes. In addition, it claims that the town board’s actions at the May 14 meeting, where they rescinded previous permission for outdoor entertainment, was a violation of the due process requirements of federal, state and township law.

The Notice of Claim does not specify actual damages, which they said are ongoing and include lost profits as well as the diminution of the business’s value.

The Greenwood Town Board met in an hour-long closed session, Tuesday, with their township attorney Scott Neff, but did not take any action. Bay View is being represented by attornies Shawn Reed and Steven Overom, from the Duluth firm Maki & Overom.

Neff, in response to a question from the audience at Tuesday’s town board meeting, said a Notice of Claim had been sent to the township, but no actual lawsuit had been filed at this point in time.

The Notice, dated June 3, was served to Greenwood Township, Julia Maki, all five town board members, Treasurer Delores Clark, and Clerk Ellen Trancheff. The Notice also said that the named parties are not permitted on the premises of BayView without prior written approval by the owner or a court warrant.

The township, at their May meeting, passed a resolution rescinding any past permission for outdoor entertainment that had been granted by the town board as part of their liquor license application approval. The township had permitted, the last two summers, outdoor music during specified hours as part of the business’s liquor license. The township is now asserting that live outdoor music on the decks at the bar/restaurant is a violation of the business’s conditional use permit and has threatened to revoke the CUP if outdoor music is permitted.

Previously, Planning Director Julia Maki has noted that using the decks for outdoor music was never mentioned during the 1999 CUP process. She also said the township does have the authority, under its zoning ordinance, to regulate uses that are not specifically stated in the ordinance. The township’s zoning ordinance does not mention outdoor music or noise.

The township held a public hearing on the issue in May.

At that hearing, Shawn Reed, the attorney representing Bay View operator Alissa Sundberg, said since there are no current ordinances dealing with noise that the issue didn’t fall under the purview of a CUP.

“If there are no ordinances,” he said at the hearing, “there are no standards. You cannot assure that all will be treated the same.”

Public input on the matter has been mixed, with many supporting the business and their right to have outdoor music as a way to attract customers and generate income, but with many others speaking eloquently of their right to enjoy their own property without being subjected to loud music.

The outdoor music has generated numerous complaints from neighbors across Big Bay, who have objected to the late-night noise. In addition, nearby neighbors have complained about rowdy behavior after hours on the property.

Bay View, which is operated by Vermilion Ventures, underwent a change in ownership last fall, with co-owner Alissa Sundberg taking full control of the business. Sundberg is also the owner/manager of the Sawmill Saloon in Virginia. Sundberg is now living on site, and acting as the hands-on manager.


4 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment

Haven't been to Bay View this year, only went once last year. Left immediately after a meal on the deck as the " music" was not enjoyable, it was too lord for conversation. Bay View may have to keep their music inside. Here's hoping that the Greenwood board and attorney Mr. Neff had done their homework. Amplified music-live or recorded HAS NO PLACE OUTDOORS on the water of a mostly residential area. The sound travels and is nothing like music when it reaches our homes. Great way to reach out to the neighbors Alyssa- sue them to get your way-which is disturbing the peace! We have the legal right ti the quiet enjoyment of our property, goes way back to old English law. Stick to doing the right thing Greewood Board! Trespassing local residents/ elected officials? Ridiculous way to reach out and get support.

Sunday, June 16, 2013

The caterwalling has begun. Today, June 22nd beginning at appx. 6 p.m. Bayview had live, amplified NOISE on their deck. 8:41 p.m..-still disturbing the peace. Inconsiderate.

Friday, June 21, 2013

Ah, a threat to sue; a shining example of Alissa wanting to be a good neighbor. The MPCA Regulations prohibit amplified outdoor music in our area which is Zone 1. Also, Greenwood Township Board of Supervisors rescinded their mistaken permission for Bayview to have amplified music on the deck. The 1999 Conditional Use Permit for building the deck was for expanded seating and some protection under the gazebo while patrons were waiting for seating in the indoor dining room. Amplified outdoor music was neither sought, nor approved, for the deck.

However, Alissa thumbed her nose at any restrictions and played amplified outdoor music on the deck last Friday, June 21st. "Hard Rock Miner" posted the above comment complaining about this. I humbly ask her to email or call the Township Supervisors to advise them of Bayview's violations, if she has not done so. I have done this. They need to know, as none of our Supervisors live in an area that can hear this musical assault on those who can. Mary Worringer

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

The absurd techno music on THE DECK (with a dj I believe ) kept us up till nearly 1 am. the evening of the flotilla. I called the bay view about 12:15 am and politely asked them to turn it town. They did not. Yesterday (7/12) more caterwalling was assaulting the enjoyment of the day. Enough already! Greenwood board- please stand fast and do not allow this obnoxious intrusion of noise to continue

Sunday, July 14, 2013