Look up and down the main street in the town closest to where you live. Whether it’s Cook, Ely, or Tower, you will find a lot of small businesses, most owned by local folks who are ready to retire or are thinking seriously about it.
That’s not a guess. Here in Minnesota, the Center for Rural Policy and Development, or CRPD, reported in December 2024 that 53 percent of Minnesota business owners are over age 55, and sources like the Census Bureau note that nearly one-in-four is over 65. In Minnesota, only about 19 percent of business owners surveyed by CRPD had worked on a written succession or exit plan in the past three years. And a succession plan is hardly a guarantee of a successful transition. In 2022, nationwide, about 92 percent of business exits were closures. Only five percent were sales that kept the doors open.
The implications of these statistics are staggering, particularly in small, isolated communities like ours here in the North Country, where the loss of a local business can mean having to travel long distances or simply doing without the goods or services they once provided. It isn’t just customers who are affected. Many of our small, independent businesses are employers as well. When those businesses close, neighbors lose jobs they once depended on.
We’ve been watching this trend unfold in the pages of this newspaper for years. We can pull out a paper from 25 years ago and page through the advertisements and find dozens of small, independently owned shops and other businesses from around our region that used to advertise regularly, right up through their “Going Out of Business” sales. As they shutter their doors, the economic activity once associated with that business, including their ad dollars that once supported local media, disappears with the closure.
That matters. When smaller communities lose their local retail shops or service providers, the local dollars that used to support those businesses tend to go elsewhere, mostly to big box or online retailers. Economists know that when we spend our money with a locally owned business, those dollars circulate through the local economy multiple times, helping to create the economic vibrancy we all want to see in our communities. When those shops are replaced by dollar stores or other big box retailers or service providers, those dollars are simply vacuumed away into the bank accounts of corporations located in far distant places.
Unlike local business owners, the chain stores rarely give back to the community. Consider the recent Tower-Soudan Athletic Association fundraiser, an annual event that features both live and silent auctions as a means of raising money for local youth sports. When you look at the items donated, it’s like a who’s who of local small businesses. The same could be said of any fundraiser in any of our communities here. Now, imagine half of them disappearing in the next ten years. It’s a very real possibility.
The good news is that there are organizations working in our region who have been raising the alarm and working toward solutions. Earlier this year, the group Ely for Ely spotlighted this issue and has teamed up with Minnesota Extension to raise awareness in the community about the importance of helping area businesses transition to the next generation. That’s critical work.
Other organizations, like the Northland Small Business Development Center, run by the Northland Foundation, or the Entrepreneur Fund can assist both business owners and potential future owners find each other and assist in a transition, through tools like loans or loan guaranties, business valuation, and business planning. And we would encourage area small business owners who are contemplating their exit strategy to reach out at an early stage in that process. If you know of a small business owner who is thinking of retirement, talk to them about it and let them know there is help out there. Sometimes, small business owners are too busy with the day-to-day to search out such resources or even think about what comes next.
Policymakers have a role to play as well. When thinking about economic development, we can’t solely focus on attracting new businesses. Some states have set up offices specifically intended to work with small business owners seeking to transition to the next generation. That can be a new owner, or the employees of a small business themselves, who can form cooperatives or similar legal structures to help maintain and even build on existing businesses.
It’s really a matter of connection— connecting viable local business with the resources, expertise, and prospective new leadership to keep the lights on in our locally-owned businesses for generations to come. It isn’t easy work, but the payoff can come in many ways for our communities.