BABBITT- Questions about city-owned land set the tone for Tuesday’s Babbitt City Council meeting, as a resident sharply confronted a city employee over trail clearing, another challenged the sale of the West Babbitt development, and the council returned to an unresolved ownership question involving a vacated road behind Cherry Circle.
Bike-and-hike trail
Allison Hillman did not mince words as she questioned city maintenance supervisor Tony Chamberlain about a recently cleared strip between Babbitt’s bike-and-hike trail and a nearby dirt road used by ATVs.
Hillman and fellow resident John Postudensek had discovered that about 100 feet of underbrush had been cleared near the trail. When they sought an explanation at City Hall, Hillman said they were given two conflicting accounts. One was that the work was connected to a possible snowmobile trail reroute. The other was that it was intended for tick prevention for people walking their dogs.
Hillman said neither explanation made sense.
“Tick prevention explanation doesn’t match what was actually done,” she told the council. “Standard tick management involves mowing the immediate edges of an existing path in spring or summer, not cutting a brand-new connecting corridor at the start of a trail in October.”
She said the location and shape of the clearing looked like preparation for a route connecting snowmobiles to the bike-and-hike trail, despite no discussion or authorization by the council.
Chamberlain said the council had not approved a reroute, and he initially described the cleared area as a possible option the council could consider in the future. He said the question arose because the nearby road that snowmobilers have used for access could become a private driveway if sold to property owner Rich Evenstad.
“You’re 100 percent correct. The City Council has not made any decisions about anything,” Chamberlain said.
Hillman then left the podium and moved closer to the table where Chamberlain was seated, directing her remarks to him. Clearly frustrated by the shifting explanations and what she saw as a breakdown of city procedure, she said a city employee should not begin work on a prospective project without council approval.
“The way it looks is that you’re taking this upon yourself when you don’t have project approval from the City Council,” Hillman said. “You don’t have the right of decision in the state of Minnesota to develop.”
She said residents walk dogs on the trail and warned that allowing snowmobiles or ATVs onto or across it would change the character and safety of the city property. She also said any such plan would need public review and involvement from the council, the snowmobile and ATV clubs, and the Department of Natural Resources.
“You do not have the right of decision to start projects that you believe are good, bad, indifferent. It doesn’t matter. It doesn’t have City Council approval,” Hillman said.
Chamberlain said he had considered brushing the area more generally and that an employee had completed the clearing while Chamberlain was away on vacation. He denied directing the employee to do it and said no trees had been removed.
Hillman was not persuaded, noting that the narrow corridor had been cleared where a possible connection to the trail would be, rather than along the broader trail system. She said city staff had effectively begun work toward a reroute before the public or council had considered it.
A representative of the Babbitt snowmobile and ATV club said the area is not part of any mapped trail system. Postudensek presented several alternative routes that could be considered if a new snowmobile connection is eventually needed and asked the city to protect the bike-and-hike trail from motorized traffic.
Council member Duane Lossing said the city should examine all options before considering a reroute. The council agreed to send the matter to its streets committee for review before bringing it back to the full council.
West Babbitt sale questioned
Later, resident Richard Pierce asked the council to delay the planned closing on the sale of the West Babbitt development for 90 days, until April 1, while he seeks further review by state officials.
Pierce argued that the city is selling the development too cheaply and without giving residents a meaningful opportunity to buy individual lots. He questioned the sale to Solum Holdings, which is affiliated with the developer involved in the project, and expressed concern that a private buyer could benefit from public investment in the development.
“I don’t think the community understands the value of what was transacted here,” Pierce said.
Pierce asked how much money the city, state, and Iron Range Resources and Rehabilitation Board had invested in the first phase. Lossing put the amount at about $4.2 million.
The city’s West Babbitt project information lists an estimated project cost of $4.45 million, including $2 million in state bonding, $1.665 million from the IRRRB, and a $785,000 general obligation bond. The city awarded the Phase 1 infrastructure contract to Rachel Contracting in 2025 for just over $4.049 million.
Pierce argued that the sale should also reflect the value of the underlying land and the city’s years of development work. He said the approximately $1.8 million sale price for the four-phase project did not account for the future value of individual lots or the eight acres planned for multifamily housing.
Lossing disputed Pierce’s arithmetic, saying Pierce was applying prices for finished lots with sewer, water, streets, and lighting already installed to land that, in the later phases, remains undeveloped.
“What we sold them basically was about 70 acres of a hayfield,” Lossing said. “It was not developed.”
Lossing said the city retains ownership of the water, sewer, and other installed infrastructure, while Solum Holdings will bear the cost of extending infrastructure through later phases. He also said the sale would spare the city from directly undertaking future development work and give the buyer an incentive to market Babbitt and bring in new residents.
Pierce also questioned the lack of a more public marketing effort. City officials said individual lots had previously been offered through the city website, although they were uncertain whether the opportunity had been advertised in the newspaper.
The council took no action on Pierce’s request to delay the closing.
Cherry Circle ownership still unresolved
The meeting began with the latest installment in the city’s ongoing question over the old road behind Cherry Circle.
Evenstad has sought to purchase the parcel for access to property he wants to develop. The issue is whether the city actually owns the land. While the county had previously vacated the road, council members discussed whether ownership reverted to adjoining property owners or remained with the city.
City officials said title work, estimated at roughly $1,200, is needed to determine whether the parcel can legally be sold. The council agreed the research should be completed before any sale can move forward, with the funding question to be considered through the city’s economic development authority.
For now, the land remains in limbo, not clearly a road, not clearly a city parcel, and not yet anybody else’s.